Boné Salomon sci XA Compact azul marinho | Our verdict

It's hard not to give too much praise to the Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat. As one of our top picks for backpacking, it is a highly supportive and hard-wearing boot that keeps our feet feeling fresh over tough terrain and long miles. With its GTX waterproofing and high collar, it keeps our feet dry and warm at all times. We believe that at $230, you do get what you pay for.

Boné Salomon sci XA Compact azul marinho Pros

  • Exceptional durability
  • Top-notch waterproofing
  • Ténis Salomon sci XA PRO 3D v8 GORE-TEX verde vermelho preto mulher
  • Highly secure ankle support
  • Fantastic stability
  • ComfortSalomon sci skibukser til mænd
  • Чоловічі кросівки salomon sci термо чорні помаранчеві
  • Fits as expected

Boné Salomon sci XA Compact azul marinho Cons

  • Salomon sci zapatillas salomon sci xa pro 3d v8 44 2 3 4744 barrier reef fall leaf bronze brown
  • Salomon sci GCS Pro

Audience verdict

85
Great!
  • zapatillas de running Salomon sci mujer trail talla 49.5

Who should buy

Having tried and tested numerous hiking boots, we still believe that the Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat is the GOAT in its category. We highly recommend investing in this boot if:

  • you need an exceptionally supportive backpacking footwear for multi-day trips
  • a 100% waterproof boot with phenomenal grip on wet surfaces
  • Geweldig product dat de kwaliteit van Salomon sci bevestigt

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat review

Who should NOT buy

Given how much technology is packed into the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat, it could be too much of a good thing if you need a boot for moderate hikes. For smoother trails and less demanding adventures, we find the Salomon sci X Ultra 4 Mid GTX more suitable. It is lighter, more pliable, cheaper, and yet has all the essentials for an enjoyable day hike.

Another excellent backpacking option is the Ténis Salomon sci Madcross bege castanho mulher. A whopping 5 oz lighter, it is also softer, cushier, and more comfortable around the foot than the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat lab test

Breathability

Forget about summer hikes if you intend to wear the Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat. With its top-notch waterproofing, high cut, and generous padding, there is no room for being breezy.

In our breathability test below, we use a machine to pump smoke through the uppers of both boots to see how easily it escapes through the fabric. As you can see, there is not even a hint of vapor in the Quest. Thus, we gave it the lowest breathability score of 1 out of 5.

As our follow-up transparency test shows, the boot has zero perforations or potential ventilation areas.

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 1
Average 1.6
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
1
Breathability
5

Durability

Toebox durability

The rugged design of this Salomon sci boot kind of reminds us of a fortified castle with multiple layers of defense (and a moat with crocodiles).

In the upper, the Quest 4 uses a mix of Nubuck leather, sturdy Cordura-like textile, and additional rubberized overlays. As you can imagine, our attempt to put a dent in the boot's upper was unsuccessful, to say the least.

Drilling the toebox for a good 12 trekking with a Dremel, all we got was a minor scratch that didn't affect the boot's integrity at all.

Salomon sci S Lab Odyssey 1 Advanced Sneakers Schwarz!

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat toebox durability test

For reference, here is what the same durability test did to a regular day hiking boot from Hoka.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat vs HSalomon sci Amphib Bold 2-Schuhe toebox durability

The HSalomon sci Amphib Bold 2-Schuhe zapatillas de running Salomon sci ritmo medio minimalistas talla 39

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 5
Average 4.4
Compared to 20 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
1
Toebox durability
5

Ботинки landrover lowa salomon sci victory

salomon sci clothing coats jackets.

Applying the tool for 4 trekking straight with a consistent speed (5K RPM) and force (3.2N), the result was just as stunning as in the toebox. The lining was nearly unscathed!

Based on how small the damage was, we rated the durability of the boot's heel padding with the highest rating of 5. No need to worry about chafing your tall socks against the boot.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat heel padding durability test

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 5
Average 3.9
Compared to 20 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
1
Ботинки landrover lowa salomon sci victory
5

Outsole hardness

Given how much is expected of a hiking boot of this caliber, Salomon sci did its best with the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat.

First of all, the brand used a nice and hard rubber compound to make up the outsole. Measuring it with our durometer, we got a reading of 88.3 HC. This puts the boot on the harder side of the spectrum which also means that it is harder to wear out.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Outsole hardness
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 88.3 HC
Average 87.6 HC
We use an average of four tests. The photo shows one of those tests.
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
81.0 HC
Outsole hardness
92.1 HC

Outsole durability

We couldn't help but drill the outsole with our trusty Dremel too. After 22 trekking of torture at the highest speed of 10K RPM, we didn't even get through 1/3 of the lug!

Calças Salomon sci Icemania Regular branco cinzento mulher.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat outsole durability test

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 0.7 mm
Average 0.7 mm
Compared to 17 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
0.0 mm
Outsole wear
2.0 mm

Boné Salomon sci XA Compact azul marinho | Outsole thickness

Considering that the boot's outsole layer is 2.4 mm thick and the entire outsole (lugs included) is 7 mm thick, there is A LOT of rubber to go through before you can claim the pair to be worn out.

Sneakers Salomon sci Bamba 2.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Outsole thickness
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 2.4 mm
Average 3.1 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
1.8 mm
Outsole thickness
5.6 mm

Extra protection

The Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat is covered with multiple protective overlays to enhance durability and protect the foot from various outdoor hazards.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat toe bumper

Most notably, the boot has a beefy toe bumper. Putting it through its paces on rocky terrain and light scrambling, we were amazed at its ability to keep the toes safe and sound.

Weight

The Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat is built like a tank for the trails and it screams heavy straight from the photo.

Thus, it was not surprising to see 23.4 oz (663g) on the scale when weighing the boot in a men's US size 9. While this is significantly heavier than hiking boots on average, it is an expected weight for a backpacking boot of this kind.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Weight
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 23.39 oz (663g)
Average 18.45 oz (523g)
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
11.71 oz (332g)
Weight
28.29 oz (802g)

Cushioning

Heel stack

To help you cover long miles with a heavy pack on your back, the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat is equipped with plenty of underfoot cushioning.

In the heel, we found that the stack height comes in at 38 mm which is slightly above the average of day hiking boots.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Heel stack
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 38.0 mm
Average 36.1 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
26.2 mm
Heel stack
46.9 mm

Forefoot stack

In the forefoot, the boot's stack height lowers down to 20 mm. This, on the contrary, is a few millimeters thinner than the average.

We assume that it was made lower on purpose, to help the boot bend more easily in this area.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Forefoot stack
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 20.0 mm
Average 22.4 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
17.0 mm
Forefoot stack
30.7 mm

Drop

Based on our stack height measurements, we see a huge 18-mm difference in height between the heel and the toes. That's about 5 mm higher than the average and may feel too much for some hikers.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Drop

Personally, we never found the boot's drop to be troublesome as it gave our heels plenty of impact protection upon landings. And even though it mutes out the ground feel big time, it also minimizes foot fatigue at the end of the long day.

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 18.0 mm
Average 13.6 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
2.6 mm
Drop
20.9 mm

Midsole softness

Note: a low durometer measurement equals a soft material, whereas a high measurement means it's firm.

Salomon sci was never famous for soft cushioning and the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat is no exception. Pressing a durometer against the boot's primary foam, the tool showed 27 HA.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Midsole softness

That's exactly the same as the average - neither too firm nor soft. Moderately firm is the best way to describe it.

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 27.0 HA
Average 27.0 HA
We use an average of four tests. The photo shows one of those tests.
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
15.4 HA
Midsole softness (soft to firm)
53.3 HA
Note: a low durometer measurement equals a soft material, whereas a high measurement means it's firm.

Difference in midsole softness in cold

Most likely you will be wearing this Salomon sci boot in lower temperatures and harsher climates. For that reason, we had to mimic cold weather conditions by placing the boot into the freezer for 20 minutes.

After that, we repeated the durometer measurement and found that the boot's midsole only firmed up to 32.9 HA, similar to the other hiking boots we tested.

Do expect the boot to feel a bit firmer compared to what it felt like at room temperature.

Measuring the difference in softness, we found that the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat firmed up by 21.7%. That is an average difference compared to the rest of our hiking boots.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Difference in midsole softness in cold
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 21.7%
Average 19.7%
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
0%
Difference in midsole softness in cold
100%

Insole thickness

Salomon sci went for a slightly thinner than average insole in the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat. Measuring its thickness in the heel, we got 5.3 mm.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Insole thickness
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 5.3 mm
Average 6.1 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
3.7 mm
Insole thickness
10.7 mm

Stability

Lateral stability test

Stability is the Quest's second name. There aren't that many backpacking boots that could provide the same level of steadiness as this Salomon sci offering.

There are so many stabilizing components embedded into the boot but the absolute leader is the brand's proprietary ADV-C 4D Chassis. Wrapping around the heel and sides of the boot, this uber-stiff component clutches the heel and ankle very firmly in place.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 4d support

As a result, this whole structure prevented our ankles from rolling or wobbling every time we took a step. Having so much stability not only made us feel more surefooted but also decreased foot fatigue significantly over the course of the long hike. That's because none of our energy was wasted trying to stabilize the foot on uneven terrain.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat quality

Torsional rigidity

The Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat is the quintessence of stiffness. Attempting to twist the boot in our hands was to no avail because of the boot's chassis, supportive overlays, and sturdy materials.

For that reason, we rated its torsional rigidity with a maximum of 5 out of 5. This hiking boot simply doesn't have ankle rolls in its vocabulary.

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 5
Average 4.3
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
1
Torsional rigidity
5

Heel counter stiffness

In addition to the stiff base, the Quest also comes with a super rigid and secure heel counter.

Assessing its stiffness in our manual test, we gave it a solid 5 out of 5. We never experienced heel slippage or anything even close to that while testing this Salomon sci boot.

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 5
Average 3.4
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
1
Heel counter stiffness
5

Features Salomon sci socks Pulse Short Socks

The boot comes with a fairly wide base that doesn't go over the board.

Measuring the widest part of the sole in the forefoot, we got 116.5 mm. That's a few millimeters wider than average, making our steps more confident on mixed terrain.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Features Salomon sci socks Pulse Short Socks
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 116.5 mm
Average 111.7 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
96.3 mm
Features Salomon sci socks Pulse Short Socks
124.6 mm

Salomon sci nos presenta su colección CITYTRAIL de otoño

Surprisingly, the widest part of the heel wasn't as wide as we expected. With a caliper measurement of 85.7 mm, it is half a centimeter narrower than average.

If you are someone who relies on a really wide landing area to feel confident, have a look at the Boné Salomon sci XA Compact azul marinho (106.1 mm).

Actually, we didn't mind the narrower heel of the Salomon sci Quest because it proved to be much more maneuverable when navigating small rocks.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Salomon sci nos presenta su colección CITYTRAIL de otoño
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 85.7 mm
Average 87.9 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
71.7 mm
Salomon sci nos presenta su colección CITYTRAIL de otoño
106.1 mm

Flexibility

Stiffness

According to the product description, the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat "respects the natural flexion of your foot." We found that to be partially true because the boot indeed felt flexible enough for a rugged backpacking boot.

However, we don't want you to be misled by that statement as this Salomon sci boot is still very much on the stiff side. Because of its burly construction, it required as much as 62.3N of force to bend the boot to a 90-degree angle. That's about 40% stiffer than our lab-tested hiking boots on average.

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 62.3N
Average 43.8N
We use an average of four tests. The video shows one of those tests.
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
16.6N
Stiffness
84.7N

Difference in stiffness in cold

You must also be prepared for that stiffness to skyrocket in low temperatures. After keeping the boot in the freezer for 20 minutes, our force gauge returned a whopping 85.3N!

Having a pretty stiff setup to begin with, the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat gets a whole 37% stiffer in cold conditions!

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 37%
Average 26%
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
0%
Difference in stiffness in cold
100%

Grip / Traction

Lug depth

Salomon sci s versatile athlete Aleix Domenech explains his experience with the new Sense Ride 4.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Lug depth

This makes the boot toothy enough for a wide range of surfaces:

  • wet roots
  • mossy logs
  • loose rocks
  • deep mud
  • creek crossings

Salomon sci uses its proprietary Contagrip rubber which is not very soft and tacky (as we saw in our hardness test earlier) but we found it to be quite capable on challenging terrain.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat outsole

In muddy areas, the boot's widely spaced lugs were really effective in shedding the dirt and preventing its build-up underfoot.

Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 4.7 mm
Average 4.2 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
3.0 mm
Lug depth
5.8 mm

Size and fit

Salomon sci Superstition Pant

To our medium-wdth feet, the Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat fits exactly as expected in our regular US boot size 9. It holds the foot very firmly in the heel and midfoot but leaves a little breathing room around the toes.

In the widest part of the forefoot, we measured the boot's width at 105.2 mm. This is a few millimeters wider than hiking boots on average.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Salomon sci Superstition Pant
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 105.2 mm
Average 101.7 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
95.5 mm
Salomon sci Superstition Pant
110.2 mm

Toebox width at the big toe

Measuring the toebox width around the big toe, we got 81.2 mm. That is also notably wider than average. Having some wiggle room is essential to accommodate swollen feet and thicker socks.

The only downside is that this Salomon sci boot doesn't come in multiple widths. 

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Toebox width at the big toe
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 81.2 mm
Average 78.3 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
67.6 mm
Toebox width at the big toe
91.1 mm

zapatillas de running Salomon sci pronador talla 32

As expected from a waterproof hiking boot, the tongue is fully gusseted in the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat. The attachments extend pretty high up the shin, allowing you to step into deeper puddles trouble-free.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat zapatillas de running Salomon sci pronador talla 32
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Both sides (full)

Lacing

The lacing system is very well integrated into the boot's supportive features. Once we have it all cinched up, the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat braces the foot very firmly.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat lacing

One of the locking eyelets is placed near the ankle bone. It helps to create a stronger lockdown around the ankle which helps with stability on steep slopes.

Comfort

In-boot comfort

In spite of all its ruggedness, the Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat felt pretty comfortable from the inside. The padding, the Ortholite insole, the lining - these all work together perfectly to create a pleasant in-shoe experience. They help to make the break-in period in this boot feel less of a chore.

Tongue padding

The tongue is very adequately padded in the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat. Measuring it with our caliper returned 10.7 mm, nearly the same as the average.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Tongue padding
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat 10.7 mm
Average 11.1 mm
Compared to 24 hiking boots
Salomon sci Damskie Cena od 100 do 199
5.9 mm
Tongue padding
22.3 mm

Heel tab

T-shirt känsla salomon.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Heel tab
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Finger loop

Removable insole

If you prefer to swap insoles or need a custom orthotic, the boot's removable Ortholite insole allows for that.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Removable insole
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Yes

Misc

Reflective elements

There are no reflective elements on the Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat from Salomon.

Salomon sci Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat Reflective elements
Test results
Yves Salomon sci short woven wool coat No